CoCoReviewBench - Thoroughness: leaderboard

CoCoReviewBench (2026) evaluates AI peer reviewers on ICLR and NeurIPS papers against category-specific human review opinions that were filtered for correctness using reviewer, author and meta-review discussions. This board measures how completely the review covers the human opinions in each category on a 1 to 5 judge scale, shown as the difference from the leave-one-out human reviewers, so positive values beat the humans; higher is better.

Metric: Category-level thoroughness score (how completely the comments cover the human opinions of the category) on the 1-5 judge scale, printed as the difference from the human reference reviews (2.37, leave-one-out: one human review scored against the others), so a positive value is better than the human reviewers and the range is -1.37 to +2.63; AI reviews of 1,300 ICLR and NeurIPS papers sampled from CoCoReviewBench (100 per year, original score distribution kept), each split into atomic opinions and compared category by category with the filtered human opinions by a GPT-5-Mini judge at temperature 0, general models prompted with the AI Scientist review prompt at temperature 0.6; higher is better. Source: arxiv.org. Saturation forecast: Around 2029. 17 models tracked. Updated 7 Oct 2026.

Top models

#ModelSettingScoreOverall rank
1GPT-5.20.64#185
2GPT-5 Mini0.58#364
3DeepReviewer-14B0.28#844
4DeepReviewer-7B0.2
5Gemini 3 Pro0.16#145
6Gemini 3 Flash0.13#175
7QwQ-32B0.13#907
8Qwen 3 32BThinking0.12#972
9nemotron-3-nano-30B-a3BReasoning0.12#1946
10Qwen 2.5 7B-0.06#2929
11Qwen 3 8BNon-reasoning-0.1#1873
12CycleReviewer-8B-0.14
13OpenReviewer-8B-0.17
14Llama 3.1 8B-0.22#5196
15CycleReviewer-70B-0.22#1880

No result here: #1 Claude Fable 5.2, #3 Gemini 4 Neon, #4 GPT-6.2 Astra.

Interactive version: theaggregate.ai/benchmark?slug=cocoreviewbench-thoroughness · How It Works · Data refreshed daily, snapshot 2026-11-21.